skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

I've been there about 4 times since I "discovered" this restaurant/ bar/ grill about 6 months ago. G
I've been there about 4 times since I "discovered" this restaurant/ bar/ grill about 6 months ago. Great bar and bartenders (best Manhattans around), simple but excellent cuisine (from hamburgers and sandwiches to great pasta dishes), great service (every time) and reasonable prices. Will definitely go back... as often as possible!
Manuel R. via yelp.com - May 25, 2022
Very nice place, very good food ... read more
Marcelo Walitzky via google.com - May 21, 2022
Enjoyed another meal at the Black Horse. Great lemon drop! This is a shout out to the host staff on Friday evening who handled an entitled patron with grace.
Lisa Breede via google.com - May 3, 2022
The pluses - We could sit outside with our dogs and eat and the waitress was awesome. The not so good - my mother ordered a $10 bowl of beef stew that came in a bowl with a huge rim and not much of a bowl. The "stew" was thin and had, literally, 2 pieces of meat in it and came with oyster crackers. They don't serve bread anymore. She ... read more
Kathy Rizzo via google.com - May 3, 2022
Friendly bar with pretty decent food selection!
Rich L via google.com - Apr 21, 2022
Waitress was awesome....when the dinning area was hopping!! Food excellent!! A must when you are in town!! A fun reflexed atmosphere!!
Joseph Govoni via google.com - Mar 29, 2022
Winchester is so fortunate to have this gem of a restaurant... and I am so lucky to have this restau
Winchester is so fortunate to have this gem of a restaurant... and I am so lucky to have this restaurant so nearby. I started coming here years ago with my husband even though, at the time, we lived 20 minutes away from it. Now, since we moved to Winchester we eat here on average about twice a week. The atmosphere is so cozy and fun ... read more
katie m. via yelp.com - Mar 23, 2022
I've had every entree they offer by this point....I can't tell what is my favorite.....I can just state that everything offered was delicious with bursting flavors and great thought process for the accompaniments. I'd recommend this restaurant to those who have a wide palate of flavors with an understanding of good food and are will ... read more
Penny Hoene via google.com - Mar 17, 2022
Nice pub in Winchester. Decent food at decent prices. Good local pub! đź‘Ť ... read more
Claudio Luciani via google.com - Mar 17, 2022
I have eaten here twice, ordered two different flatbread pizzas (blue cheese steak & pulled pork bbq) and have to say the food is incredible. These flatbread pizzas are some of the best I've had anywhere. Highly recommend giving these a try, and am looking forward to tasting the rest of the menu.
Dmitriy Khesin via google.com - Mar 16, 2022
Service is great but food has gone downhill the chowder had hardly any clams and very few potato's i
Service is great but food has gone downhill the chowder had hardly any clams and very few potato's in it the sauce was meh I could not finish the first meatball took one bite and felt sick to my stomach think I got food poisoning I'm dealing with this morning service is great though overall I will stick with the entrees over the apps ... read more
Jeff D. via yelp.com - Feb 13, 2022
This is a very good local "pub" that serves good basic American dishes and some different ones like
This is a very good local "pub" that serves good basic American dishes and some different ones like a lamp burger. It is however always very crowded for dinner which makes it a very crowded and very noisy place to have a conversation. So my advice is to avoid the Tavern if you actually want to converse with a family member or friend.
Ron T. via yelp.com - Feb 4, 2022
Their steak tips are phenomenal!
Their steak tips are phenomenal!
Paul Petrillo via facebook.com - Jan 27, 2022
Very nice and cozy place! My friend and I went there on a cold day, and we asked for hot chocolate a
Very nice and cozy place! My friend and I went there on a cold day, and we asked for hot chocolate as soon as we sat down, and they actually serve it! The food was delicious. My friend devoured the Shepard's pie and I enjoyed the ravioli. What a gem in Winchester!
Justin S. via yelp.com - Jan 2, 2022
The Black Horse Tavern was the first Tavern downtown. The First Pub arrived post this Tavern. I always found this menu here interesting. I found it difficult to find what I want like a piece of dish, baked potato and a veggie. Today, I tried the cup of chili with a side salad. Both dishes were very good. In fact, taste wise, I ... read more
Jim Haynie via google.com - Dec 30, 2021
Good salmon dish and nice atmosphere ... read more
Roy Blum via google.com - Dec 27, 2021
Great location, tasty meals, lots of room and tables ... read more
Ann Pendleton via google.com - Dec 20, 2021
Outstanding food and friendly staff make this a great local spot.
David Sensale via google.com - Dec 12, 2021
Awesome food, awesome service all at a reasonable price.
Awesome food, awesome service all at a reasonable price.
David Sensale via facebook.com - Dec 11, 2021
The BHT has the most delicious and fresh food around. We ordered the eggplant fries, spinach artichoke dip and each got our own entree. I ordered the Dijon salmon and my fiancé got a Cheggy burger. We couldn’t stop talking about how good everything was all night. Really nice ambiance and nice servers. Great drinks too!
Jessica Anderson via google.com - Dec 10, 2021
great food and atmosphere ... read more
Bill Murphy via google.com - Dec 8, 2021
Amazing food and exceptionally friend staff; we've visited several times, and the food and service arevonsistently great. It's a favorite place of ours to bring out of town guests!
Alex F via google.com - Nov 29, 2021
****Read Full Review**** GREAT food and great atmosphere. Wife and I have been here 7 times so far it it is our favorite place in the area. HOWEVER...every. single. time. we have been here (yes, all 7 times) we have been charged 1 extra drink and we have had to ask the bartender to take it off. It is so reoccurring we have no choic ... read more
Alex Robinett via google.com - Nov 28, 2021
Good tastes and really fresh food! I like it ~ I had the hamburger and chicken wings.
Grace Fu via google.com - Nov 18, 2021
Went here with a group of six people and I had the shepherds pie. It was the best I’ve ever had.
Went here with a group of six people and I had the shepherds pie. It was the best I’ve ever had. It was piping hot out of the oven and tasted amazing. Lots of ground angus beef, corn and peas topped with delicious mashed potatoes.
Steve Halverson via facebook.com - Nov 14, 2021
I went ther with a group of six and had a great meal. The menu offered lots of choices and the blood
I went ther with a group of six and had a great meal. The menu offered lots of choices and the bloody Mary's were very tasty. I ordered the shepherds pie and it was the best I've had. Lots of good ground angus beef and veggies topped with a nice helping of mashed potatoes.
Steven H. via yelp.com - Nov 14, 2021
Great Food and Great Service, Timely and Very Great Environment.
Great Food and Great Service, Timely and Very Great Environment.
Willie D. via yelp.com - Nov 11, 2021
We had a delicious late lunch. It was a beautiful fall day and all the windows were open. It is a fun, casual atmosphere. The food was delightful. The waitstaff was attentive but not hovering.
Andrea Hanley via google.com - Oct 27, 2021
I don’t think I’ve ever been to a restaurant/bar/pub where I ordered food and wasn’t given silverware and a napkin… then asked for them (people forget no worries!) but then still didn’t receive them. Still a good location, decent food and variety.
Katy via google.com - Oct 26, 2021
Love it here ... read more
Erin Papaleo via google.com - Oct 26, 2021
Sitting outside. Wonder what was on tap? Had the haddock sandwich, the fish a little soft (the chees
Sitting outside. Wonder what was on tap? Had the haddock sandwich, the fish a little soft (the cheese didn't do much for me), crispy fries. bland slaw, friendly enough service.
Dan R. via yelp.com - Oct 26, 2021
The menu has something for everyone, even people with food allergies and restrictive diets. The service is reliably good even when they are short staffed. The ambiance is chill. The patio is really nice. All around good place.
Kate Petersen via google.com - Oct 23, 2021
The ambiance and service of this place is stellar. I love the patio and the overall atmosphere. The
The ambiance and service of this place is stellar. I love the patio and the overall atmosphere. The food was okay and the drink selection was also okay. I would say it's definitely worth a try but it definitely wasn't mind blowing. I got the prosciutto, fig and caramelized onion flat bread with a blueberry ale. I wish the flatbread h ... read more
Misa S. via yelp.com - Oct 13, 2021
1st time eating here (outside), did takeout 2 or 3 times before. Really is one of the better places in Winchester. Wide, varied menu with lots of options. We love the brussel sprouts as a starter. Lots of good comfort food and not too expensive.
Travis via google.com - Oct 9, 2021
steak tip salad - excellent!
steak tip salad - excellent!
Will Currier via facebook.com - Oct 2, 2021
Everything about this place is incredible ... read more
Ken Stebbins via google.com - Sep 24, 2021
Very expensive, not worth it ... read more
Jacob Evangelista via google.com - Sep 20, 2021
The best would recommended it !
The best would recommended it !
Maureen Kelly Brooks via facebook.com - Sep 16, 2021
Great atmosphere and location. Best of all, great food.
John Arvanitis via google.com - Sep 12, 2021
Great drinks, loved the eggplant fries appetizer, very nice wait staff ... read more
Catherine via google.com - Sep 9, 2021
Great food and reasonable prices ... read more
Chris H via google.com - Sep 8, 2021
Good help that tell you if food is gluten free. Great đź‘Ť help.
Kathleen Stearns via google.com - Sep 6, 2021
Truffle fries are great here. Worth a trip!
Andrew L via google.com - Sep 4, 2021
Solid spot to watch the games ... read more
Chris Traer via google.com - Sep 2, 2021
Fresh homemade food with a lively atmosphere. They did an amazing job with their outdoor area and th
Fresh homemade food with a lively atmosphere. They did an amazing job with their outdoor area and those BEAUTIFUL flowers! It's always such a pleasure going to black horse. Last time i ordered the black and blu flatbread and the steak tips! Simply delicious and cooked to perfection!!
Barb M. via yelp.com - Sep 2, 2021
Third visit. Food always good, service fine, outdoor dining plentiful.
Third visit. Food always good, service fine, outdoor dining plentiful.
Susan L. via yelp.com - Aug 24, 2021
(Translated by Google) Excellent place and food !!! (Original) Excelente lugar y comida!!!
jorge moroni chiappa via google.com - Aug 20, 2021
This has got to be the BEST restaurant in Winchester! The food is good, the live music is good, the staff are nice, and the parking is usually good. Normally there is a pretty lengthy wait around dinner, but that is good too because that means people enjoy the food, no? ... read more
Henry Marks via google.com - Aug 17, 2021
This was our first time here. Prime time dinner rush with a preschooler and they exceeded every expe
This was our first time here. Prime time dinner rush with a preschooler and they exceeded every expectation. Our drinks were on point, well balanced and yummy. For apps, we settled on the eggplant fries and mozzarella sticks which were amazing. Homemade and crispy. Entrees: baked scallops, steak tip flatbread, turkey tips and kids ho ... read more
Sherilyn P. via yelp.com - Jul 22, 2021
Solid American pub with a good atmosphere and located in downtown Winchester. Sometimes there is a wait but service is quick once seated.
Derek Straub via google.com - Jul 19, 2021
Just utterly amazing. The flavor profiles and unique food options is something to appreciate. The sp
Just utterly amazing. The flavor profiles and unique food options is something to appreciate. The spaghetti squash? To die for. I'm EXTREMELY picky on food and flavor. I mean, I've tried out for 2 National cooking shows 3 times. I grew up with Italians from New Orleans. Flavor profile is EVERYTHING to me. We tried: Brussels (Crispy d ... read more
Erin P. via yelp.com - Jul 16, 2021
What a nice spot. We had the chance to visit with the entire family on Saturday night, 7/10/21. Beau
What a nice spot. We had the chance to visit with the entire family on Saturday night, 7/10/21. Beautiful setting with outside seating and inside seating with wide-open windows for the summer breeze! We started with appetizers (coconut shrimp and wings). Both were fantastic and plentiful. Our server was fantastic....around and ready ... read more
Ed M. via yelp.com - Jul 12, 2021
I have had a marginal experience at Blackhorse. My family enjoys the burgers and steak but the chicken dishes are really questionable. Last night I had a kale and quinoa salad w chicken. Kale is supposed to be sautéed lightly before putting in a salad— it was just thrown from a bag with a heaping of quinoa. Presentation wasn’t nice e ... read more
Martha S via google.com - Jul 10, 2021
Since moving to the area, I have looked all over for the "hometown" bar feel that makes you want to
Since moving to the area, I have looked all over for the "hometown" bar feel that makes you want to be a regular, pours them well, and does not disappoint with a range taking menu. "Farm to Table" remains hot in the Instagram street, but I prefer "Bar to Table"...Can a restaurant preform from belly on the bar to the tablecloth. I hav ... read more
Gorilla I. via yelp.com - Jul 10, 2021
Ordered a lot of food here for the first time. It was very close to closing, so I wasn't expecting much or even edible food for that matter. The gentleman who had greeted me was very nice. My food was ready quick. My son had steak tips, I had mushroom ravioli, and my boyfriend shared spaghetti and meatballs with my picky 5 year old.( ... read more
Mary W via google.com - Jun 26, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire